4/19/2023 0 Comments Task coach portableWe would have to review every change in the code of every release to ensure he didn't add anything that would negatively impact our users or users of any forked version of the app. Based on the Facebook spamming, erratic and numerous email messages, and his public statement about this on his site, I'm disinclined to trust the base code enough to maintain the mild fork mentioned above. Though he has released his code under the Eclipse license, it's become clear he doesn't want anyone to utilize the rights given under the license, claiming it is 'his' code and anyone else using it is 'stealing'. Existing users who wish to continue using the app can run the ToDoList Portable to ToDoList zip converter to switch to non-PAF TodoList.īased on additional interactions with the author, I've decided to remove ToDoList completely. This whole incident is especially odd considering that it was the author who requested we add ToDoList originally. Based on this and additional behavior like Facebook spamming, this seemed the best option. Though he has released his code under the Eclipse license, it's become clear he doesn't want anyone to utilize the rights given under the license. UPDATE (Mar 16, 2014) - After additional interactions with the author, we have decided to remove ToDoList completely. Though not required, I've let the publisher know that we may be making the TDLister fork to continue supporting our users. But I'd like to get some thoughts from the community before I make the final decision. I have TDLister just about prepped and can push it out to our users tomorrow if I decide to go that route. We kept the name similarity since CoolPlayer was abandoned. We did something simlar when CoolPlayer Portable became CoolPlayer+ Portable and we added some functionality and fixed some security issues. The app would continue to function exactly as it does today and all users will be automatically upgraded with all data intact. I'd like to maintain a link to the original author's donation page, but am unsure if he'd even want us to do that. The author's original copyrights will remain, of course, and we'd be distributing the source under the Eclipse license as required. It would have a new icon and remove the links pointing to the original author's support pages and email. This mild update would rebrand it as TDLister Portable and would only add about 10 minutes to packaging time. We could even investigate writing a converter to help users transition from ToDoList to Task Coach.Ģ) The other option is to do a mild fork of the app, renaming and rebranding it lightly to avoid the issues the original author is worried about (our work reflecting on his). For users wanting a supported task app from us, we'd point them to Task Coach, whose developers ship a PAF package directly. Most users will be unable to use the app's built-in update checker as it requires admin rights. We can then point the existing users to AbstractSpoon for any future updates to be applied by the user. We have a couple options that are more appealing.ġ) We can write a custom installer to convert existing users' installs to a standard ToDoList zip install and have a custom message show as they upgrade that the app is no longer in PAF format, will not be upgraded by the platform, will be incompatible with the platform's app data backup function, and will no longer be supported by. Technically, we could simply continue to package it over the author's objections, as it is open source under an Eclipse license and the name is not trademarked, but I'd prefer not to. Leaving them stranded isn't really an option. I pushed a revision to ToDoList Portable this morning that takes into account users saving to App and preserves their data on upgrades.Īs we have around 500k downloads of ToDoList Portable (it's more popular than the base app itself), I'd wager there are maybe 100k active users of the app. I wasn't aware of this when we began speaking as I didn't write the original package, I simply helped keep it updated. The base app saves to its own directory by default and the PAF package did not take that into account. He is also upset by the dataloss issue that occurred with a handful of users who saved their data within the App directory and lost it on upgrade. The author has indicated a dislike of the PAF package as some users have apparently been turning to him for support despite downloading it from us, seeing our splash screen, and having our help file next to the launcher. I wanted to let folks know that, at the publisher's request, ToDoList Portable is temporarily unavailable.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |